by Nina
Side Plank Pose (photo “borrowed” from Wall Street Journal) |
I’ve been hearing for some time that a single yoga pose, Side Plank pose (Vasisthasana), is particularly beneficial for people with scoliosis (see Friday Q&A: Scoliosis). In my post Late-Onset Scoliosis is Common in Older Adults, I wrote about a New York Times article that said that late-onset scoliosis, a condition I have myself, is actually more prevalent in adults than it is in adolescents. The author of that article, Jane Brody, is not a regular yoga practitioner, but she described a “yoga exercise” that was recommended to her after she found out about her late-onset scoliosis.
“Determined to minimize further shrinkage and to avoid pain and nerve damage, I consulted a physiatrist who, after reviewing X-rays of my misshapen spine, said the muscles on my right side, where the spinal protrusion is, were overdeveloped relative to the left. He prescribed a yoga exercise — a side plank — to strengthen the muscles on the left and exert enough of a tug on my spine to keep it from protruding farther to the right. He suggested that the exercise might even straighten the curve somewhat. And I myself had the same pose, Side Plank pose (Vasithasana) recommended to me by my chiropractor (yes, I have a chiropractor for my scoliosis—I don’t believe that yoga is the answer to everything), so I have incorporated this wonderful strengthening pose into my regular yoga practice.”
Now a recent scientific study, which was reported in the Wall Street Journal article Study: Doing the Side Plank Reduced Spinal Curving in Scoliosis Patients, found that for a small group of patients with scoliosis (21 women and four men, ages 14 to 85) practicing this one pose resulted in a curve reduction of almost 50 percent among teenage practitioners and 38 percent for adults. Yes, they studied just this single yoga pose!
“In this study, we assess the possible benefits of asymmetrical strengthening of truncal muscles on the convex side of the scoliotic curve through a single yoga pose, the side plank pose, in idiopathic and degenerative scoliosis.”
For this particular study, they recommended that the participants do the pose on one side only, “with the convexity downward.” For information on the original study, see Serial Case Reporting Yoga for Idiopathic and Degenerative Scoliosis.
While this study of Side Plank pose is—like so many other scientific
studies of yoga—limited by the small number of participants being studied and
the lack of control group, there is no question in our minds that this is an excellent strengthening pose. In his post Friday Q&A: Yoga for Surgically Repaired Scoliosis, Baxter mentioned Side Plank pose as one of the strengthening poses that he recommended for strengthening the muscles at the front, back, and sides of your body. Shari says the pose strengthens the serratus anterior, the obliques, the latisimus, quadratus the lumborum, the gluteus muscles, the fasciae latae, hamstrings, scapula stabilizers, teres minor and major, and then all the paraspinal muscle stabilizers. Wow that’s a lot of muscles! That’s why we recommend this pose for anyone who wants to build upper body strength. And I’m betting that strengthening those paraspinal muscles (the muscles all along the spine) is particular beneficial for people with scoliosis.
So today seems like a good day to review our instructions for how to practice this pose. For people who don’t yet have the strength to do the pose on the floor, we provide the option of doing the pose with one hand on the wall. You can practice the wall version regularly until you build up the strength to do the floor version.
Side Plank Pose on the Floor
1. Start by taking Downward-Facing Dog (Adho Mukha Svanasana) pose.
1. From Downward-Facing Dog, swing your shoulders forward almost into Plank position while keeping your hips lifted.
3. Make your right arm stronger by contracting the muscles of the arm to the bone, and tip your heels to the right, bringing the outer edge of your right foot and the inner edge of your left foot to the floor, with your feet slightly apart.
4. Turn your chest away from the floor and bring your left hand onto your left hip. Since this takes a lot of strength, stay just few breaths at first, and gradually add more time with more practice.
5. To come out, swing back into Downward-Facing Dog pose
6. Unless you are practicing on one side only as in the study, repeat the pose on the second side. Afterward, rest in Child’s pose a few breaths.
Side Plank Pose on the Wall
1. Start with your right side to the wall.
2. Reach your right arm out to your side, parallel with the floor, and place your palm on the wall with your fingers pointing up. Engage your right shoulder blade into your chest wall and down slightly towards your right waist.
3. Step both feet out away from the wall, until your right foot is positioned directly under your left shoulder.
4. If your balance is good, try bending your left knee and bringing your left foot into Tree pose (Vrksasana).
5. Take your left arm up and overhead, reaching strongly towards the wall with your left arm and shoulder blade, aligning it like the top arm in Extended Side Angle pose (Utthita Parsvakonasna).
6. Unless you are practicing on one side only as in the study, repeat on the second side.
Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to Amazon, Shambhala, Indie Bound or your local bookstore.
I'm wondering if the pose should be done on only one side to correct the imbalance. If so, advise on how to determine which side would be useful to me.
Edward, because I learned my original comment was incorrect (see comments from readers below), I have deleted that comment.
Hi Nina, I'm still having trouble identifying which side i should do the side plank on. Could you help enlighten me?
Jeffrey, you should do the pose with the convex side of your curve closest to the floor. So if your convex side is on your right, you would have your right hand on the floor. If you don't know which side is your convex side, you should ask a health practitioner or yoga teacher who understands scoliosis to help you figure it out. It's not something that I can advise you on without seeing you because people tend to get confused about this.
"said the muscles on my right side, where the spinal protrusion is, were overdeveloped relative to the left. He prescribed a yoga exercise — a side plank — to strengthen the muscles on the left and exert enough of a tug on my spine to keep it from protruding farther to the right. He suggested that the exercise might even straighten the curve somewhat" This is what made me wonder. If the curve is to be "tugged" back into more alignment one sided work might be indicated. Of course in normal practice both sides get done. Here some therapeutic change might be wanted. Elise recommends one sided work with Janu Sirsasana. I always have trouble figuring out which side to do though. Any help there would be very welcome.
"Twenty-five patients with idiopathic or degenerative scoliosis and primary curves measuring 6 to 120 degrees by the Cobb method had spinal radiographs and were then taught the side plank pose. After 1 week performing the pose with convexity downward for 10 to 20 seconds, they were instructed to maintain the posture once daily for as long as possible on that one side only. "
http://www.gahmj.com/doi/abs/10.7453/gahmj.2013.064?journalCode=gahmj#/doi/full/10.7453/gahmj.2013.064
Thanks so much for adding this, Maria! I have deleted my original comments.
More detailed summary of the Fishman et al. article here:
http://www.unitywoods.com/2014/10/practice-adolescent-scoliosis/
The practice was one-sided -"asymmetrically strengthening the convex side of primary curve"
Thanks for this important information, Anon!
The original study refers to performing the asana on one side only and the resulting improvements. Given the degree of confusion about this issue here in the comments, I think it merits further discussion.
Yes, you are absolutely right. I have actually deleted my original comments as even though I had consulted with Shari, who is a physical therapist as well as a yoga teacher, she was not familiar with the specific study. So for our purposes, I've decided to let the study speak for itself. And I'm very grateful to you for adding this detail from the study.
This study is good news for those suffering from scoliosis. I've a lumbar curve, convex to the right. When I first read this I immediately thought I should do the side plank with my left side downward. It seemed logical since my left oblique is softer and the my right oblique which is harder. However after reading the full paper I realized I was wrong.
You should do the plank with the convex of your bigger curve downward, in my case it should be with my right side close to the floor. It seems muscles has a push effect rather than a pull effect.
The paper says: "The spine will bend toward the stronger side, and thus, the muscles of the convex side may be weaker than their smaller-appearing counterparts on the concave side."
Also it was used other side plank positions for patients with more complex curves.
If you can, have a look at the full paper: http://www.gahmj.com/doi/full/10.7453/gahmj.2013.064
I'm almost 100% certain of my interpretation, can anyone verify this? I don't want to end doing the side plank on the wrong side…
same…. i've a lumbar curve , curving towards my right side… (right muscle more developed)
which side do i put my hand on the floor for the side plank? right/left?
If your spine is curving toward the right (that is the convex side) and it is a simple curve (not an "S" curve), then you put your right hand on the floor. (If you are not completely certain about which side is your convex side, please consult your health professional for an assessment.)
this is my xray as seen from behind of my back. (as if you're standing behind me looking at my back)
http://gyazo.com/e1966b7afbd6e75b8fb844169bfc4d71
curve going -> right…
convex to the right..
concave to the left…
Thank you for the reply Nina. :) will try out the side plank…
Hi there, what to do with a s shape scoliosis?
2 single yoga poses?