by Baxter

While in Montreal for a weekend workshop, I found myself attending a modern dance performance. I’d say the average age of the performers was about 30, and all looked very fit and flexible. As part of their performance, they did a move in which they leapt forward while spinning and landed on the floor in a Pigeon-pose like stance. The first time they did this, I found myself wincing, as I imagined the impact on their knees on the firm, uncarpeted dance floor. I’d have to guess they did this at least five more times, and usually always landing on the same knee. My host and I spoke about this after the show, and we were both of the opinion that no good could come of this for the future health of these dancers’ knees.

Trauma to the knee is one of several risk factors for the development of arthritis of the knees later in life. It was no coincidence that one of the attendees at my weekend Anatomy and Yoga workshop has arthritis in his knees at the ripe age of 40, as he had been dancing for over 20 years and had suffered numerous injuries to both knees over that time. But since starting his yoga a few years back, his knee pain had improved to the point that after a hiatus of almost 10 years, he was gradually returning to some dance.

In addition to trauma, other risk factors for developing osteoarthritis (the most common form of arthritis) of the knee include: 

  • weight, as in more body weight, more stress on the knee joint 
  • sedentary lifestyle, as it seems that some activity is better for the knee joint than no activity 
  • work or hobbies that involve repetitive demands on the knees, such as horseback riding, which encourages a bowing outward at the knee joint and places unusual stress on the knee joint 
  • bone abnormalities, which some people are born with and could include skeletal issues such as bow legs or knock knees 
  • other diseases like hypothyroidism and Paget’s disease, which could lead to arthritis over time advancing age 
  • gender, that is, women, for reasons that are not yet clear, have a higher incidence of arthritis than men 

Typically, in a healthy knee joint, just as in the hips, the surfaces of the top bone, the femur, and the bottom bone, the tibia, are covered in a layer of protective connective tissue known as cartilage. The cartilage acts as both a shock absorber when the bones move close to one another, as when you are walking or running, and also as a smooth, slick surface for the bones to slide over one another when you are doing any knee bending activities.

If any or several of the risk factors are present, the usually smooth surfaces can become rough, like sandpaper, which may or may not produce pain, but could produce some grinding sounds from the knees. Eventually, the cartilage could wear through and expose the underlying bone, which is even rougher. When bone on bone contact starts to occur, it usually results in inflammation in the joint, which then swells, can become hot to touch and limited in movement and painful. Since the condition usually worsens over time, especially if you don’t seek help for it, it could eventually lead to significant immobility and pain. I am going to assume you have had the common sense to see you family MD to get an accurate diagnosis and have tried some of the western treatment options, such as medications, physical therapy, and braces, and such and are looking for alternative ways to work with the knees to avoid worsening of your situation and surgery.

Yoga is both helpful in addressing the acute problems of swelling and pain, and the longer-term issues of improving mobility, strength and stability of the knee joints. 

In acute situations, restorative practices or reclining sequences can allow for you to maintain some gentle movement of the knee while reducing the effects of gravity on the knee that occurs when you stand. A regular favorite when the knee is swollen is any reclining posture that elevates the leg higher than the chest. My personal favorite is Legs Up the Wall pose (Vipariti Karani). Another is the door jam version of Reclined Leg Stretch (Supta Padangustasana_, where you lie down on the floor on your back at a doorway, your hips lined up with the doorway, and take the affected leg up in the air and rest the heel on the door jam. This allows for a more passive approach to this pose that we usually do with a strap on the foot of the lifted leg.

In addition, a whole slew of other reclining poses can be performed that are safe for the knee and allow you to get some of the stress-reducing benefits of a regular home practice (see Timothy’s post from yesterday Home Practice: The Best Way to Improve Your Health and Well-Being). On top of helping to quiet down an inflamed knee, you can use your practice to strengthen the muscular/tendonous support around the knee. Engaging the muscles that surround the knees simultaneously has been shown to benefit the joints, as Shari noted in a post a while back on hips. So I recommend starting with poses in which the knees are extended or straight, as this reduces sheering actions on the cartilage. This includes Mountain pose (Tadasana), Triangle pose (Utthita Trikonasana), Pyramid pose (Parsvottanasana), Wide-Spread Standing Forward Bend (Prasarita Padottanasana), and such. If these are done successfully, without aggravating your knees, and are hopefully bringing some gradual improvement in your symptoms, you can add in standing poses with knees bent. This will require that you pay special attention to the trajectory of the knee as you flex it. Ideally, you will want to bend the knee directly in line with your mid-foot, so the knee is tracking in the most anatomically correct way. You may want to have your local yoga teacher help you to figure this out, as it is a bit difficult to sense on your own at first.

Another potential way to modify seated poses to allow you to do them pain free is to use some sort of a spacer tucked into the back of your knees before you deeply flex (bend) the knees. You can use a rolled up washcloth, or a thinly folded yoga blanket. Once you place the spacer in the fold of the back of the knee, mindfully bend the knee and see how it feels. There should be no pain. If you have a history of ACL repair (anterior cruciate ligament), then never use a spacer, as it could loosen this precious repaired tear.

Since every arthritic knee is going to be a bit different, these suggestions are offered to get you thinking about ways yoga could be helpful for you. As I always say, it would be a good idea to do some one-on-one work with an experienced teacher to guide you safely on your way.

And skip the Flying Twist Dropping Pigeon from your repertoire until next lifetime!

Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to Amazon, Shambhala, Indie Bound or your local bookstore.