by Nina
Uh, oh! I feel a rant coming on. It all started when a yoga person posted the above graphic with a question: Are you embracing the lockdown? Or resisting it? To be honest, the question made me a bit angry. I immediately thought of all the people around the world who had lost their loved ones, had lost their jobs, had lost their homes, were killing themselves with work to help those in need, were sick themselves, and so on. Were they supposed to look at the pandemic as an “opportunity”? And if they weren’t “flourishing” right now, was that somehow their own fault because they didn’t take the proper attitude toward their situation? Then, there are those of us who are privileged enough to have jobs, food, a place to live, etc. Should we still be expected to flourish during this difficult time? For example, should someone who has been living alone without experiencing any human touch for more than seven months, with no end in sight, be expected to see their new, completely solitary life as an “opportunity”? So, yeah, I couldn’t resist commenting. I said that I felt this duality was neither kind nor helpful. And I asked whether there wasn’t something in between these two “opposites,” something more along the lines of acceptance? The post felt very judgmental to me, but I did try to be polite in my response.
But it got me thinking. Later in the day when I was taking a walk with Brad, I told him about what had happened. He said something I thought was so perceptive:
“Did you ever look at a plant that has gone through a long drought? It’s obviously not flourishing! But it has survived. That’s all we need to do right now—survive. There will be time to flourish later.”
We live in an area that is regularly plagued by droughts as well as forest fires, so I was easily able to picture a majestic redwood tree, like the ones I love to visit in the Muir Woods, with its needles dry and brittle but its core strong and solid, waiting patiently for the winter rains to return.
And I thought about the Bhagavad Gita. I told Brad that in that story, the man-god Krishna is counseling Arjuna, who is about to face great difficulty: going into a battle where he might be forced to kill relatives and beloved teachers. Although Krishna strongly encourages Arjuna to do his duty as a warrior and fight the battle he has signed up for, he does not tell Arjuna to “embrace” the “opportunity” before him. Instead, he tells him to take the yogic approach to the his work, which means facing the difficulty with an attitude of equanimity, or an evenness of mind.
“Set thy heart upon thy work, but never on its reward.
Work not for a reward; but never cease to do thy work.
Do thy work in the peace of Yoga and, free from selfish desires, be not moved in success or failure.
Yoga is evenness of mind—a peace that is ever the same.” —translated by Juan Mascaro
In the end, after much discussion, Arjuna accepts Krishna’s advice, committing to a yogic approach, and enters into the battle. Do you ever wonder what happens after that? The end of the war is actually tragic. Arjuna does survive, but the war is a complete disaster and both the armies, Arjuna’s and the one he and his brothers are fighting against, are slaughtered. Afterward, Arjuna is cursed by Gandhari, King Dhritarashra’s wife, for allowing that slaughter to take place. Eighteen years later, at the end of his life, Arjuna does achieve enlightenment, but he has a lot more difficulty to get through before that happens. To put it bluntly, even after he “embraces” yoga, his life is not a lush garden of spring flowers.
All of this is why I think the duality of “threat” vs. “opportunity” is a false one and is a way of thinking that makes light of the true nature of difficulty, including the challenge of surviving through a global pandemic. On the other hand, yoga does provide us with a solution that is both more helpful and more compassionate for those who are living through difficulty: cultivating equanimity. As the Bhagavad Gita tells us, a yogi is one:
“Who unperturbed by changing conditions sits apart and watches and says ‘the powers of nature go round’, and remains firm and shakes not.
Who dwells in his inner self, and is the same in pleasure and pain; to whom gold or stones or earth are one, and what is pleasing or displeasing leave him in peace; who is beyond both praise and blame, and whose mind is steady and quiet.” —translated by Juan Mascaro
So, don’t let anyone shame you for not choosing to “embrace” the difficulties you’re facing these days. Instead, simply use whatever yoga practices help you to stay steady throughout these challenging times. And if you find yourself at your wits end now and then, have as much compassion for yourself as you would for another.
Follow Yoga for Healthy Aging on Facebook ° To order Yoga for Healthy Aging: A Guide to Lifelong Well-Being, go to Amazon, Shambhala, Indie Bound or your local bookstore.
Hi Nina,
I had to take some time to process your blog. I did not have the same reaction to the picture that you did. I saw it as demonstrating a personal choice of intention (among all the various reactions one can have), not necessarily a "this OR that" choice. I have been touched in many ways by the pandemic, the fires, inconvenience of extended power loss due to the threat of fire, illness and death over these months. It is a heavy emotional
time, there is no doubt.
I have had times of breakdown, tears, anger, displacement, the whole range. Coming back to the equanimity that I seek is up to me. At times I am in the fight with Arjuna.Maybe I am not successful in every moment, but in many moments I am. I try to teach my students how to find their own emotional sea level (Dr. Andrew Weil) and to know this too is a process, not a static state.
I am aware that some folks can see this as" this or that choice". Even as someone who has "lost" a lot thru this time, I endeavor to replace that loss with growth, peace, kindness and a new beginning.
Thanks so much for this comment, Genevieve! And I appreciate your honesty. To me, your words express more depth, subtlety, and truthfulness than the illustration.
Doing my best to survive my personal drought so I get an opportunity to flourish in the future. Setting the bar at getting through this with my sanity intact and still able to feel compassion for others is the goal. You're right. Picturing this as a binary choice is not fair, or wise, or kind.
Those seem like very good goals to me. I hope yoga can help you with both of them.
Thank you Nina, for this very thoughtful piece. Even though I'm accustomed to isolation, and I've learned to engage coping strategies – I've struggled.
There's no easy path but acknowledging survival is the end game helps take the pressure down a notch.
I'm learning when I've reached my limit, (and I have new limitations), and when to ask for help. And also am giving myself permission to rest when I need it.
I'm glad taking the pressure down a notch is helpful for you. And giving yourself permission to rest when you need it is so beneficial. After all, we can't help others or ourselves when we burn ourselves out.
Nina, your piece is very thought-provoking, in some part because my first thought was of SWOT analysis in the business world (Strength/Weakness/Opportunity/Threat) and it threw me for a bit of a loop – but your response was very leveling, as it always is. No matter how we'd like it to be Life is rarely Either/Or. Giving ourselves permission to see nuances, to give ourselves (and others) a break, to choose to be kind (which is not a weakness)… all those things will give us strengths needed to go forward. xoxoxo
The lockdown has affected me in many ways, but Is just part of life. Adapt where possible.